Skip to main content

Fascinating stories about phantom limbs

The feeling of sensation where a limb used to be has been documented for hundreds of years, although the term "phantom limb" didn't appear in medical texts until the latter half of the 19th century. Popularized by Civil War-era doctors like S. Weir Mitchell and French physician Albert Pitres, the phenomenon because the topic of much superstition well into the 20th century.

It was generally believed that in order to prevent phantom limb sensation, it was necessary to bury the severed limb as far away from the patient as possible, preferably with full funeral rites. This led to some rather interesting burials. For instance, one newspaper article from 1909 relates a strange event in Illinois:

J.H. McNinch of Rock Falls and James Borges of Maywood, who lost their right arms Saturday morning in a wreck of a Northwestern passenger train near West Chicago, implored that the amputated right arms should be properly embalmed and then shipped to the respective family burying grounds of McNinch at Rock Falls and Borges at Maywood. Dr. Isherwood, their physician, familiar with the strange superstition, obeyed the orders of the injured men to the letter and Untertaker C.E. Norris of West Chicago embalmed the two right arms, had them packed in wood caskets and Wednesday they were shipped with instructions that they be buried with funeral rites.- Belvidere Daily Republican, Sept. 6, 1909.

Although this superstition was practiced extensively in America, there are several accounts in which limb burials failed to achieve the desired result. In some cases, it even made things worse. One of the strangest stories involving phantom limbs took place in Kansas in 1881, and involved a boy whose arm had been amputated and buried.

A singular incident is reported by The Emporia Ledger of a young man who recently had his arm amputated while under the influence of chloroform. The arm was amputated and buried some twenty miles from Emporia, and the young man taken to the latter place. At times he complained of feeling a pain in the hand of the buried arm on account of the fingers being closed upon the thumb. The arm was exhumed, and the fingers found just as the boy had described. Again he said it pained him, because the fingers were bent. This was found to be true also, and the hand was straightened out and buried again, when all the pain ceased and the boy said he rested better.- The Leavenworth Times, Oct. 15, 1881.

Prof. Albert Pitres, an early pioneer of phantom limb research

This type of mysterious phenomenon has been well-documented:

-A man whose right leg had been amputated and buried complained of cramps in his left leg, and when the leg was exhumed it was found to be in a bent position. After the exhumed leg was straightened, the man's cramps went away. (1)

-A farmer who lost an arm began to complain that he felt small stones between the fingers in his phantom limb. When the arm was exhumed, it was discovered that several small pebbles were lodged between the fingers. (1)

-An Oklahoma oilman named Anderson Pugh had his leg amputated and soon began feeling cramps in his phantom leg. He implored the church sexton to dig up the leg and straighten it out, which the sexton did. Pugh's pain immediately went away. (1)

-Another Oklahoman named Elmer Mize lost an arm in a railroad accident and experienced phantom pains in the hand of his severed limb, claiming that the hand was bent doubled. The arm was exhumed and the hand was indeed doubled, as Mize had claimed. Unfortunately, so much time had elapsed that that it was impossible to straighten the hand of the decayed limb, and Mize's phantom pains never went away. (1)

Similar incidents were reported by several leading physicians of the day, including Professor Pitres, who recalled meeting an old soldier who had lost both feet. The old man would sit for a half hour at a time massaging the ends of his shoes, where his corns used to be. "There's going to be a change in the weather, my corns are hurting me," the old man would declare. On being reminded that he no longer had corns, he would say, "Nevermind! I feel 'em all the same!" (2)

While research into phantom limbs is still taking place, modern science has failed to come up with many definitive answers as to how or why this phenomenon occurs. Could it be possible, at least in the cases mentioned above, that there is some form of telepathy involved? How else could one explain how an amputee can feel the pebbles between the fingers in his buried hand, or how a boy can perfectly describe the position of a severed arm that was buried twenty miles away?

(1) Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, March 30, 1917
(2) The Plain Speaker (Hazleton, PA), June 14, 1898

Marlin Bressi is a freelance writer, creator of the Pennsylvania Oddities blog, and author of the book Hairy Men in Caves: True Stories of America's Most Colorful Hermits.

Popular posts from this blog

The Incest Capital of the World?

At the far eastern edge of Kentucky, nestled in Appalachia, resides Letcher County. In spite of its isolation and poverty (approximately 30% of the county's population lives below the poverty line), Letcher County has managed to grow at an impressive rate, from a population of just 9,172 in 1900 to a present-day population of nearly 25,000. However, even if Letcher County tripled or quadrupled its present population, there's still a pretty good chance that virtually all of the county's inhabitants would be related to each other-- thanks to one particularly fertile family whose astounding rate of reproduction can put even the friskiest rabbit to shame.

Around the year 1900, Letcher County was the home of a man by the name of Jason L. Webb, who made national headlines for having the one of the largest families in the world. According to newspaper reports of the era, Jason had 19 children, 175 grandchildren, and 100 great-grandchildren. Perhaps even more impressive was his b…

The Ticking Tombstone of Landenberg

If you look closely at a map of Pennsylvania, you'll see an anomalous semi-circular border at the extreme southeastern part of the state. This circle, known officially as the "Twelve Mile Circle", serves as the border between the Keystone State and Delaware. Much of the strange circle is surrounded by Chester County, one of the three original Pennsylvania counties created by William Penn in 1682. While there are many historical points of interest in Chester County, few are strange or as steeped in legend as the Ticking Tombstone.

Near the London Tract Meeting House in Landenberg is an old graveyard which contains a tombstone which is said to make eerie ticking noises, much like the ticking of a pocketwatch. Landenberg locals claim that the ticking is the result of two very famous surveyors who arrived in town during the 1760s- Charles Mason and Jeremiah Dixon.  A young child supposedly swallowed a valuable pocketwatch owned by Mason and later died, and the boy's head…

Jenny Hanivers, Mermaids, Devil Fish, and Sea Monks

Three centuries before P.T. Barnum attracted flocks of crowds with his mummified Fiji Mermaid (which turned out to be a papier-mâché creation featuring a monkey's head and a fish's body), sailors around the world had already began manufacturing "mermaids".  Known as Jenny Hanivers, these creations were often sold to tourists and provided sailors with an additional source of income.  These mummified creatures were produced by drying, carving, and then varnishing the carcasses of fish belonging to the order rajiformes- a group of flattened cartilaginous fish related to the shark which includes stingrays and skates.  These preserved carcasses can be made to resemble mermaids, dragons, angels, demons, and other mythical creatures.

Jenny Hanivers became popular in the mid-16th century, when sailors around the Antwerp docks began selling the novelties to tourists.  This practice was so common  in the Belgian city that it may have influenced the name; it is widely believed …